Updated: 02/07/2012 19:18 | By pa.press.net

London Welsh hail appeal victory



London Welsh captain Jon Mills (© left)

London Welsh captain Jon Mills (left) and chairman Bleddyn Phillips with their Championship trophy

London Welsh have branded their promotion into the Aviva Premiership, following a successful appeal, as a victory for the whole of sport.

The Championship winners had been barred from going up by the Rugby Football Union after they failed to meet the minimum standards required of a Premiership club. The appeal centred on the fact they were being blocked from playing at Oxford United's Kassam Stadium despite three existing Premiership teams cohabiting with football clubs.

The appeals panel concluded the so-called 'primacy of tenure' rule was void because it broke European and UK competition laws, and the club said: "This is not only a victory for London Welsh, its players, coaching staff and all its supporters but also for sport in general and the game of rugby union in particular, reinforcing the ethos and fundamental sporting ethic that the best team should receive the appropriate rewards."

London Welsh also made a strong play of the fact that promotion and relegation, wherever possible, should be decided on the field of play.

The verdict reached by panel chairman James Dingemans QC, Ian Mill QC and Tim Ward QC condemned Newcastle to the drop.

Newcastle, who have no provision to appeal the decision through rugby channels, kept their options open over a challenge through the courts. But the tone of the Falcons' reaction to the decision suggested they would look to rebuild in the Championship.

"We do not underestimate the competitiveness and challenges we face in the Championship but under the tutelage of Dean Richards we will have one, and only one goal - to win," the club said.

"Dean has been in this situation with Harlequins and he understands what it takes to navigate through the Championship, whilst putting together a team that will be successful with immediate effect on our return to the Aviva Premiership."

London Welsh need to step up their recruitment programme while the RFU's priority now is to instigate a review of the minimum standards criteria, or at least what is left of them.

Not for the first time in recent months, the governing bodies of elite rugby in England have been left red-faced.

2Comments
01/07/2012 10:34
avatar
Looks like justice gas been done at last. Maybe now the RFU will listen to the masses!!
03/07/2012 13:46
avatar
Right decision  but lucky for the exiles that there were 3 QCs adjudicating otherwise the incompetent RFU whose standards are more linked to the number of bottles of champers in your Twickers hamper would have blackballed them. Not sure that this promotion will do the club any good though as they are likely to become another bankrupt club and wont even have a pot to p**s in.
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
10 reasons to make MSN UK your homepage (© Microsoft)

latest rugby news

  • Rhys Thomas retired from rugby in 2012

    Former Wales and Scarlets prop Rhys Thomas is undergoing surgery on Tuesday ahead of a heart transplant.

  • Johnny Sexton is a doubt for Ireland's autumn Test series after breaking his jaw

    Johnny Sexton faces a race against time to be fit for Ireland's autumn international Test series after breaking his jaw in club action with Racing Metro.

  • Nick Phipps will start for Australia

    Australia coach Ewen McKenzie has made four changes to his side to face South Africa as the Wallabies look to bounce back from their Rugby Championship drubbing against New Zealand.

  • Jon Fisher, centre, has joined Northampton Saints after leaving London Irish in the summer

    Northampton Saints have signed former London Irish flanker Jon Fisher ahead of the new Aviva Premiership campaign.

  • Phil Thiel, pictured, joins Saracens as short-term cover for Schalk Brits

    Saracens have signed US Eagles hooker Phil Thiel as short-term cover for Schalk Brits, who is on Rugby Championship duty with South Africa.

  • Eusebio Guinazu, left, has signed a short-term deal to join Munster

    Argentina hooker Eusebio Guinazu has signed for Munster on a four-month deal to offset Mike Sherry's long-term shoulder injury.

  • Pat Phibbs, centre, has started a second spell at Exeter Chiefs

    Pat Phibbs has returned to Exeter Chiefs on a trial basis to ease the Aviva Premiership club's scrum-half injury spate.

  • Jim Mallinder believes Aviva Premiership fixtures could be completed alongside Rugby World Cup 2015 action

    Global bosses could allow the Aviva Premiership to kick off during the knockout stages of Rugby World Cup 2015 in a bid to diffuse England's latest club-versus-country row.

  • Roger Lewis, left, believes a new peace deal is positive

    Welsh rugby has finally agreed a peace deal with 10 players receiving dual contracts in a six-year £60million-plus agreement.

  • Bernard Lapasset believes the name change will help rugby grow

    The International Rugby Board is to be renamed 'World Rugby' from November 19 in a move described by chairman Bernard Lapasset as a "mission statement".

  • Sam Burgess, pictured left, will start his rugby union career in the centres at Bath

    Sam Burgess will start his Bath career in the centres, but head coach Mike Ford still expects him to excel in the back-row.

  • Conor O'Shea, pictured, is not moved by Lawrence Dallaglio's critical comments

    Conor O'Shea has branded criticism from Lawrence Dallaglio for demoting Chris Robshaw as Harlequins captain as a "load of rubbish".

  • Quentin Smith insists talks between Premiership Rugby and the RFU over compensation are close to a conclusion

    Premiership Rugby has sought to defuse tension over the payment of World Cup compensation by promising a swift resolution to negotiations with the Rugby Football Union.

  • Marland Yarde, pictured, has been tipped to secure a starting berth for England at next year's Rugby World Cup

    Jason Robinson believes new Harlequins signing Marland Yarde is in the perfect position to win the "shootout" for a place on the wing for England at Rugby World Cup 2015.

  • Debbie Jevans is busy organising the 2015 Rugby World Cup

    The team charged with the task of delivering the 2015 Rugby World Cup is relishing the challenge of building upon Britain's blossoming reputation for hosting major sporting events.