Updated: 29/06/2012 20:26 | By pa.press.net

London Welsh on the up after appeal



London Welsh have won their appeal to the RFU and will play in the Aviva Premiership next season

London Welsh have won their appeal to the RFU and will play in the Aviva Premiership next season

London Welsh will play in the Aviva Premiership next season after winning their appeal against a Rugby Football Union decision to block their promotion.

The Championship winners were originally denied the right to go up after being told they had failed to meet the minimum standards required of a Premiership club.

London Welsh's appeal was heard on Thursday by an independent panel, who spent all of Friday deliberating over the evidence before finding in favour of the Richmond-based club. The verdict condemns Newcastle to relegation after they finished bottom of the Premiership.

London Welsh were initially told they had failed the minimum standards audit on a number of factors but primarily because they did not meet the requirement for primacy of tenure.

In effect, that meant London Welsh were not allowed to share the Kassam Stadium with Oxford United even though three existing Premiership teams co-habit with football clubs.

London Welsh argued the primacy of tenure rule breached UK and European competition law and was therefore void and unenforceable. The independent panel, which was comprised of QCs James Dingemans, Ian Mill and Tim Ward, agreed.

"We upheld London Welsh's complaint and concluded that the Primacy of Tenure rule gave rise to an unjustified distortion of competition, contrary to UK and EU competition law," the panel said in a statement.

"While the rule included exemptions for three particular Premiership clubs ('the three club exemption'), there was insufficient justification for the narrowness of that exemption and its restrictive effect on aspirant Championship clubs.

"London Welsh argued and the RFU accepted that the consequence of such a finding was that the provisions that contain the Primacy of Tenure rule in the MSC (minimum standards criteria) are void."

This is the second time the Premiership's minimum standards criteria have failed to stand up to a challenge. Rotherham complained to the Office of Fair Trading after their promotion was blocked in 2002, leading to a change in the definition of primacy of tenure.

2Comments
30/06/2012 15:14
avatar
So LONDON Welsh playing in OXFORD??
30/06/2012 16:02
avatar

Absolutely brilliant news for the Welsh in London and a victory for common sense. The RFU should abide by their own rules and not 'cherry pick' the Premiership teams.

Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
Get the Bing Sports App for Windows 8 (© Microsoft)

latest rugby news

  • Chris Robshaw is facing questions once again

    Chris Robshaw insists experience has equipped him to handle the renewed speculation over his position as England's captain and openside.

  • Bath and England centre Kyle Eastmond

    Kyle Eastmond claims that neither England nor Sam Burgess feature in his current thought process after he helped to inspire Bath's record-breaking 45-0 Aviva Premiership romp against Leicester.

  • Dean Richards' Newcastle were slow starters against Northampton

    Newcastle director of rugby Dean Richards bemoaned his side's performance in the first half hour of their 35-10 Aviva Premiership defeat at home to Northampton Saints.

  • Rhys Webb did most of the damage as the Ospreys beat Edinburgh on Sunday

    Ospreys soared to the top of the Guinness Pro12 table with a nine-try hammering of Edinburgh at the Liberty Stadium to preserve their 100 per cent start to the season.

  • Alex Dunbar scored Glasgow's first try

    Glasgow Warriors flanker Tyrone Holmes could face a ban after being sent off in his side's bonus-point victory over a woeful Newport Gwent Dragons at Rodney Parade.

  • Aaron Shingler put in a man-of-the-match display for the Scarlets

    The Scarlets bounced back from their hammering at the hands of Leinster with a seven-try, 43-0 thumping of hapless Treviso at Parc y Scarlets.

  • Northampton's Ken Pisi scored a try in his team's Aviva Premiership win at Newcastle.

    Northampton returned to winning ways in the Aviva Premiership with an emphatic 35-10 triumph over Newcastle Falcons.

  • Olly Woodburn goes over for one of Bath's tries

    England fly-half hopeful George Ford inspired a Bath romp at the Recreation Ground as hapless Leicester were ruthlessly battered into submission.

  • Chris Robshaw scored a try for Quins

    Harlequins rebounded from their surrender to Saracens by completing a stormy 26-23 Aviva Premiership victory over Wasps at Twickenham Stoop.

  • Billy Vunipola's late try spared Saracens' blushes

    A last-minute try by Billy Vunipola from a driving maul saved Saracens' unbeaten record just as a rejuvenated London Irish had seemed set to pull off a remarkable Aviva Premiership victory.

  • Richard Cockerill was dismayed by Leicester's performance

    Leicester boss Richard Cockerill admitted "we got what we deserved" after the Tigers suffered a humiliating 45-0 Aviva Premiership defeat against Bath at the Recreation Ground.

  • Brian Smith was pleased with the guts and determination shown by his team against Saracens

    London Irish director of rugby Brian Smith was proud of his side's performance despite seeing them deprived of a remarkable win over high-flying Saracens by a last-gasp Billy Vunipola try.

  • Steve Diamond wants to see his side make improvements

    Sale director of rugby Steve Diamond praised his team for their late efforts in securing a first win of the Aviva Premiership season at the expense of London Welsh, but acknowledged there was plenty of room for improvement.

  • Chris Robshaw, pictured, has certainly got the backing of Harlequins chief Conor O'Shea

    Harlequins director of rugby Conor O'Shea offered an impassioned defence of Chris Robshaw in reaction to a week of "insulting" speculation over his England future.

  • Henry Slade, right, helped Exeter beat Gloucester on Friday

    Exeter boss Rob Baxter hailed the quality of England World Cup hopeful Henry Slade after his team went top of the Aviva Premiership with a 25-22 victory over Gloucester at Kingsholm.