Updated: 29/06/2012 20:26 | By pa.press.net

London Welsh on the up after appeal



London Welsh have won their appeal to the RFU and will play in the Aviva Premiership next season

London Welsh have won their appeal to the RFU and will play in the Aviva Premiership next season

London Welsh will play in the Aviva Premiership next season after winning their appeal against a Rugby Football Union decision to block their promotion.

The Championship winners were originally denied the right to go up after being told they had failed to meet the minimum standards required of a Premiership club.

London Welsh's appeal was heard on Thursday by an independent panel, who spent all of Friday deliberating over the evidence before finding in favour of the Richmond-based club. The verdict condemns Newcastle to relegation after they finished bottom of the Premiership.

London Welsh were initially told they had failed the minimum standards audit on a number of factors but primarily because they did not meet the requirement for primacy of tenure.

In effect, that meant London Welsh were not allowed to share the Kassam Stadium with Oxford United even though three existing Premiership teams co-habit with football clubs.

London Welsh argued the primacy of tenure rule breached UK and European competition law and was therefore void and unenforceable. The independent panel, which was comprised of QCs James Dingemans, Ian Mill and Tim Ward, agreed.

"We upheld London Welsh's complaint and concluded that the Primacy of Tenure rule gave rise to an unjustified distortion of competition, contrary to UK and EU competition law," the panel said in a statement.

"While the rule included exemptions for three particular Premiership clubs ('the three club exemption'), there was insufficient justification for the narrowness of that exemption and its restrictive effect on aspirant Championship clubs.

"London Welsh argued and the RFU accepted that the consequence of such a finding was that the provisions that contain the Primacy of Tenure rule in the MSC (minimum standards criteria) are void."

This is the second time the Premiership's minimum standards criteria have failed to stand up to a challenge. Rotherham complained to the Office of Fair Trading after their promotion was blocked in 2002, leading to a change in the definition of primacy of tenure.

2Comments
30/06/2012 15:14
avatar
So LONDON Welsh playing in OXFORD??
30/06/2012 16:02
avatar

Absolutely brilliant news for the Welsh in London and a victory for common sense. The RFU should abide by their own rules and not 'cherry pick' the Premiership teams.

Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
10 reasons to make MSN UK your homepage (© Microsoft)

latest rugby news

  • Former England and Gloucester winger James Simpson-Daniel has retired through injury

    Former England winger James Simpson-Daniel has announced his retirement because of an ankle injury, Gloucester Rugby confirmed on Tuesday.

  • Rhys Thomas retired from rugby in 2012

    Former Wales and Scarlets prop Rhys Thomas is undergoing surgery on Tuesday ahead of a heart transplant.

  • Johnny Sexton is a doubt for Ireland's autumn Test series after breaking his jaw

    Johnny Sexton faces a race against time to be fit for Ireland's autumn international Test series after breaking his jaw in club action with Racing Metro.

  • Nick Phipps will start for Australia

    Australia coach Ewen McKenzie has made four changes to his side to face South Africa as the Wallabies look to bounce back from their Rugby Championship drubbing against New Zealand.

  • Jon Fisher, centre, has joined Northampton Saints after leaving London Irish in the summer

    Northampton Saints have signed former London Irish flanker Jon Fisher ahead of the new Aviva Premiership campaign.

  • Phil Thiel, pictured, joins Saracens as short-term cover for Schalk Brits

    Saracens have signed US Eagles hooker Phil Thiel as short-term cover for Schalk Brits, who is on Rugby Championship duty with South Africa.

  • Eusebio Guinazu, left, has signed a short-term deal to join Munster

    Argentina hooker Eusebio Guinazu has signed for Munster on a four-month deal to offset Mike Sherry's long-term shoulder injury.

  • Pat Phibbs, centre, has started a second spell at Exeter Chiefs

    Pat Phibbs has returned to Exeter Chiefs on a trial basis to ease the Aviva Premiership club's scrum-half injury spate.

  • Jim Mallinder believes Aviva Premiership fixtures could be completed alongside Rugby World Cup 2015 action

    Global bosses could allow the Aviva Premiership to kick off during the knockout stages of Rugby World Cup 2015 in a bid to diffuse England's latest club-versus-country row.

  • Roger Lewis, left, believes a new peace deal is positive

    Welsh rugby has finally agreed a peace deal with 10 players receiving dual contracts in a six-year £60million-plus agreement.

  • Bernard Lapasset believes the name change will help rugby grow

    The International Rugby Board is to be renamed 'World Rugby' from November 19 in a move described by chairman Bernard Lapasset as a "mission statement".

  • Sam Burgess, pictured left, will start his rugby union career in the centres at Bath

    Sam Burgess will start his Bath career in the centres, but head coach Mike Ford still expects him to excel in the back-row.

  • Conor O'Shea, pictured, is not moved by Lawrence Dallaglio's critical comments

    Conor O'Shea has branded criticism from Lawrence Dallaglio for demoting Chris Robshaw as Harlequins captain as a "load of rubbish".

  • Quentin Smith insists talks between Premiership Rugby and the RFU over compensation are close to a conclusion

    Premiership Rugby has sought to defuse tension over the payment of World Cup compensation by promising a swift resolution to negotiations with the Rugby Football Union.

  • Marland Yarde, pictured, has been tipped to secure a starting berth for England at next year's Rugby World Cup

    Jason Robinson believes new Harlequins signing Marland Yarde is in the perfect position to win the "shootout" for a place on the wing for England at Rugby World Cup 2015.