#socialvoices

Ferdinand might wish he’d kept quiet

What must Ferdinand be thinking now?

By Musa Okwonga 13/07/2012 19:37

John Terry was found not guilty of racially abusing Anton Ferdinand, Musa Okwonga argues that Ferdinand has paid a heavy price that for doing what he thought was right.

Anton Ferdinand and John Terry - PAWho would like to be Anton Ferdinand right now? He has just emerged from a trial where John Terry, the Chelsea and England defender, has been found not guilty of racially abusing him.


Whilst Terry has taken yet another barrage of public abuse, there is a strong argument that Ferdinand has paid the greater price during the affair.


Ferdinand found himself at the heart of a trial whose key moment he did not even witness until he saw it on YouTube after the game.


The date of that trial had been deferred till the summer, due to the successful arguments of Chelsea’s legal team: which meant that Ferdinand, like Terry, had to endure months of speculation about his integrity. 


Ferdinand was no angel: his baiting of Terry over his extra-marital affairs paints him in a poor light


He saw his brother, Rio, left out of England’s 2012 squad in a decision that many considered to be a direct result of the impending court proceedings. He received threats and a bullet in the post.


And for what? The magistrate’s court was not a place for Judge Riddle to deliver catharsis for Ferdinand or many members of the public, but to deliver a verdict on the facts as he saw them.


The hard reality for the prosecution is that it was unable to produce evidence compelling enough to prove its case.


Ferdinand was no angel: his baiting of Terry over his extra-marital affairs paints him in a poor light.  But, in the words of the judge, he was brave to testify, doing so on a point of principle. Perhaps, his principles, and Judge Riddle’s praise, will be of sufficient comfort to him.


As suggested by Ashley Cole, that this case would be better if it had not gone to court at all


Perhaps. Time will tell, too, whether other players thinking of making allegations of this nature will feel emboldened or chastened by Ferdinand’s ordeal. 


As it stands, he returns to a sport where his brother probably has no future with the national team, and to a small social circle which is, in all likelihood, irreparably damaged by this affair. 

 

Of course, he did the right thing and deserves only credit for his courage in taking a stand.

But the uncomfortable thought may occur to him, as suggested by Ashley Cole, that this case would be better if it had not gone to court at all: that, in the infamous words of Sepp Blatter, he and John Terry should just have shaken hands.


Musa Okwonga is a poet, musician, football writer and social commentator, you can follow him on Twitter @Okwonga


DO YOU THINK THIS CASE SHOULD HAVE GONE TO COURT? TELL MUSA ON TWITTER USING #SOCIALVOICES

leave your comment
about #socialvoices

Welcome to #socialvoices. This is the home of sharp writing, opinion and social debate on MSN. Jump into the comments, tweet us with the hashtag. Join in.

#socialvoices on Twitter
No tweets available. Please try again later
vote now

Who will finish highest in the Premier League?

Thanks for being one of the first people to vote. Results will be available soon. Check for results

  1. 64 %
    Arsenal
    502 votes
  2.  
    3 %
    Everton
    24 votes
  3.  
    18 %
    Liverpool
    147 votes
  4.  
    13 %
    Manchester United
    103 votes
  5.  
    2 %
    Tottenham
    19 votes

Total Responses: 795
Not scientifically valid. Results are updated every minute.

more from #socialvoices